Batting Out of Order or Turn in Baseball & Penalities

We use affiliate links in this article. And, as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Thanks for your support.

In the complex and rule-intensive sport of baseball, batting out of order is a rare but consequential mistake that can have a significant impact on the game’s flow. This misstep occurs when a player takes their turn at bat out of the sequence that was presented in the lineup card at the beginning of the game. In this article, we’ll delve into what exactly constitutes batting out of turn, the potential penalties and scenarios that can occur, and how teams and umpires typically handle this situation. Through a detailed exploration, you’ll gain a better understanding of this quirk in baseball’s extensive rulebook and appreciate the strategy and attention to detail required by teams to avoid such errors.

What is Batting Out of Turn?

Batting out of turn, also known as batting out of order, happens in baseball when a batter steps up to the plate and takes an at-bat outside of the official batting order submitted by the manager before the game. This order lists the nine players who will bat and their corresponding positions in the field.

Penalty for Batting Out of Order

Imagine you’re playing baseball. You have a batting order where everyone takes turns hitting. But sometimes, things get mixed up and someone hits out of order. Here’s what happens depending on when the mistake is caught:

1. Catch it Early (No Penalty):

If an error is caught before the incorrect batter completes their turn at bat, it’s treated as a do-over. The right batter comes in, adopts the wrong batter’s count (balls and strikes), and the game proceeds as if nothing went wrong.

2. Missed It Too Late (Ouch!):

If an error is noticed after the incorrect batter completes their turn but before any further actions occur in a baseball game, it becomes a more significant issue. The correct batter is declared out, impacting the team’s prospects. Any runs or base progressions achieved by the wrong batter are nullified. Nonetheless, if the mistaken batter reached base because of a teammate’s skillful play, such as stealing, or an error by the opposing team, the advancement still stands.

3. Way Too Late (Surprise!):

If the wrong batter’s turn goes unnoticed until after the next play starts, their at-bat still counts in the game. They remain in the game with any runs or advances they made intact, and the error is essentially overlooked. However, the skipped batter will get their turn during the team’s next batting round, ensuring that everyone gets an opportunity to bat eventually.

Example to Understand Batting Out of Order

Let’s say the Smithville Sluggers are playing against the Johnson City Jets in a local baseball game. Before the game starts, the Sluggers’ manager submits the lineup card to the umpire, specifying the batting order:

  1. Mike Johnson (Leadoff batter)
  2. Tom Smith
  3. Dave Roberts
  4. Chris Thompson
  5. Alex Rodriguez
  6. Mark Davis
  7. Steve Miller
  8. Matt Wilson
  9. Bob Anderson (Pitcher)

The game begins, and everything goes smoothly until the bottom of the third inning. With two outs, the Sluggers’ cleanup hitter, Chris Thompson, comes to bat. However, the Jets’ coach notices that Tom Smith, the second batter, is already in the batter’s box on deck.

The Jets’ coach, recognizing the mistake, alerts the umpire that the Sluggers have batted out of order. The umpire halts the game to address the issue.

Scenario 1: Appeal made during plate appearance
If the Jets make their appeal before any pitches are thrown to Chris Thompson, the correct batter, Tom Smith, will replace Thompson at the plate. Smith assumes Thompson’s count and continues the at-bat.

Scenario 2: Appeal made following plate appearance but before next pitch or attempted play
If the appeal happens after Chris Thompson’s plate appearance but before the next pitch or attempted play, Thompson’s at-bat is nullified, and he is called out. Any runners who advanced due to Thompson’s at-bat would return to their original bases.

Scenario 3: Appeal made following plate appearance and after next pitch or attempted play
If the Jets fail to notice the mistake until after the next pitch or attempted play, Chris Thompson’s at-bat is considered legal, and any runs or advancements resulting from his at-bat count. The Sluggers will continue their batting order from where it left off, and Tom Smith will bat in his correct order next time.

Photo of author


James Arnold
I'm James, and I live in Stanislaus County, California. I'm playing Baseball for many years, and I love this sport so much that I also encourage my kids (Danny and Sara) to play Baseball & Softball.