Best Catcher’s Mitt in 2021: For High School Baseball

*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I will get commission for purchases made through links in this post.*

Want to share it with your friends?

If you have a kid who is maybe around 13 years old and play as a catcher, then you must be looking for the best catchers mitt for high school baseball.

There are a few essential things you need to know before buying one. High-priced mitts take longer to break in compared to affordable mitts, and they differ from softball to baseball.

Also when buying online, make sure to read reviews and choose a 2021 model.

So, let’s get started.

My Personal Recommendation

If you’re looking for a durable catcher’s mitt for high school baseball that is easy to break in, then I’d personally recommend Wilson A2000 Baseball Gloves.

It is made of combined Pro Stock leather and engineered Superskin which makes it lighter and stronger. It will definitely stand up to the rigors of being a catcher every season.

This glove is a half-moon web with a deep pocket and a flat finger binding if you prefer to play with a finger outside the glove. Also, its moisture-resistant design is guaranteed to provide you with comfort all throughout your game.

 Wilson A2000 Baseball Glove SeriesAll-Star - Pro Elite CM3000SBT Baseball Catcher's MittRawlings Heart of the Hide Baseball Glove Series
MaterialLeatherLeatherLeather
Size33 inches33.5 inches33 inches
ColorMultiple optionsCream WhiteBlack
LiningLeatherSynthetic LeatherCowhide
Hand OrientationRightRightRight
PerksHalf moon web and extended palmSoft tan leather pocket Comfortable and durable
PriceCheck Current PriceCheck Current PriceCheck Current Price

Best Catchers Mitt in 2021

Best Catcher's Mitt in 2019

Wilson 2021 A2K M1D Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

Wilson’s new addition to their industry-leading baseball gloves is the A2K M1D Baseball Catcher’s Mitt. This brand new model offers a lot of impressive features that catchers will sure to instantly love. Like the other models manufactured by Wilson, the A2K M1D catcher’s glove is made with Pro Stock Select Leather chosen for its consistency and flawlessness. It is guaranteed durable and has incomparable break-in as the other gloves in the A2000 series. If you like the Wilson A2000 series but you want a more updated version, then this is the best catcher’s mitt for you.

The main difference in the construction of this glove compared to the previous ones is the all-new SnakeSkin style incorporated in this glove. It offers a sleeker and more attractive look while ensuring that the glove holds its shape for longer.

This glove features an extended palm and deeper pocket to help reduce rebound when catching fastballs or breaking balls. It also has Double Palm Construction which is a thin piece of leather placed between the palm liner and outer shell for maximum pocket stability.

The A2K M1D Baseball Catcher’s Mitt measures 33.5 inches and is suitable for right-hand throwers.

Pros
  • Made with Pro Stock Select Leather
  • Easy to break-in
  • SnakeSkin style
  • Has an extended palm and deeper pocket
  • Double Palm Construction
Cons
  • Not suitable for left-hand throwers

All Star Pro Elite Series Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

This All Star Pro Elite catcher’s mitt is one of the most popular mitts worn by many pros designed for all the serious baseball players out there. It is made with only the finest materials and hand craftsmanship by All Star to ensure top-tier quality on the mound.

The exclusive Japanese tanned steer hide material gives the gloves maximum durability that is certain to last for a long time. It has a stiffer feel and holds its shape longer compared to other mitts perfect for elite players. Because of its stiff feel, it can take some time and more work to break-in this glove, nonetheless, once broken in, this glove will fit and snug your hand like a dream.

This glove is available in multiple sizes to fit your preference. You can get it in 32-inch, 33.5-inch, and 35-inch size. It has an extended pocket and a deeper profiled toe to heighten your ability to trap and secure fastballs as well as scoop down grounders and low pitches. The Reinforced Closed Web is also employed for added catching support

It has an open back design to provide more flexibility in the wrist and hand for better hand movements. It also has a finger hood for a snug fit as well as a Velcro wrist strap to keep the glove tightly secure around your wrist.

Pros
  • Made with Japanese tanned steer hide
  • Has a stiffer feel and holds its shape longer
  • Available in multiple sizes
  • Has extended pocket and deeper profiled toe
  • Has a finger hood Open back design and Velcro wrist strap
Cons
  • Harder to break-in

Wilson A2000 Catcher’s Mitt

Another excellent baseball glove by Wilson is the A2000 Catcher’s Mitt developed specifically for active catchers behind the plate. It is crafted with an American Pro Stock Steerhide Leather meticulously selected due to its rugged durability, firm structure, and unmatched comfort. It has a stiffer feel so you might need to do a little work when breaking it in, however, it also has a smoother break-in process which enables you to shape the glove to conform to your hands better allowing you to gain the best fit possible. Inside the glove is the Dri-Lex Wrist Lining to keep your hands cool and dry making this glove a perfect all-season mitt.

This catcher’s mitt has an open back design giving you more freedom on your hands and wrist for better responsiveness. It utilizes a Half Moon Web pattern that creates a deeper pocket needed by catchers when catching fastballs and moving fastballs allowing them to secure the ball from their grip. It also offers more flexibility to prevent the ball from popping out the mitt. It also has dual welting for improved pocket stability and better support.

The Wilson A2000 Catcher’s Mitt is available in 33-inch size which can fit high school to adult-sized hands.

Pros
  • Made with American Pro Stock Steerhide Leather
  • Dri-Lex Wrist Lining
  • Has an open-back design
  • Half Moon Web pattern
  • Has dual welting
Cons
  • Harder to break-in

Nokona Alpha Select Series S-120 Catcher’s Mitt

Nokona is reputable for providing the highest quality gloves made with top-grade leathers in the USA and the Alpha Select Series S-120 Catcher’s Mitt is definitely among their top products. It is constructed with Stampede and Buffalo leathers known to have that soft and buttery feel without compromising the structure and durability. This glove is relatively easier to break-in so you can use it right out of the package and has a lighter weight feel for maximum comfort.

It utilizes a closed web pattern for extra support when catching to make sure the pitched balls are trapped inside the glove. It also has an open back design allowing the catcher to gain better hand and wrist movement when catching curveballs or moving fastballs.

The Nokona Alpha Select Series S-120 Catcher’s Mitt has a 31.50 +/- inch size available in right and left-hand throwers and is recommended for youth players. However, some pointed out that it doesn’t have plenty of padding on the palm area which can be uncomfortable when catching fast-paced pitches.

Pros
  • Made with Stampede and Buffalo leathers
  • Soft and lightweight
  • Easy to break-in
  • Closed web pattern
  • Has an open-back design
Cons
  • Not enough padding on the palm

Akadema AGC98 Prodigy Series Glove

The Akadema AGC98 glove is designed by Hall of Famer Gary Carter who is an American professional baseball catcher to ensure the gloves have all the features and design that all catchers, whether a beginner or a pro, will need and love. It also utilizes several technologies developed by Akadema to guarantee the highest quality and most efficient catcher’s mitt for all baseball players.

The glove features Akadema’s patent-pending Stress Wedge technology placed between the index finger and thumb which offers shock-absorbing protection for the hand against injury and sting when receiving the ball. It also offers two additional Finger Hammocks allowing the fingers to be firmly positioned and more secure in the glove to prevent the ball from escaping the catcher’s grip.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OJpUjvH0v2g

The overall design of the AGC98 glove mimics the praying mantis position to facilitate better ball grasp and security. It has increased pocket size and easier ball retention while allowing easier ball release and transfer. The glove uses a spiral lock web pattern that provides improved catching support without losing control over your hand positioning.

The glove is handcrafted with a select U.S. Steerhide pocket, AkademaLyte leather on the back, and Akadema ¼” Rawhide lacing. It has a 32-inch circumference pattern and is available for right and left-hand throwers. However, some mentioned that the leather is not as soft and flexible making it hard to break-in the gloves and the quality of the leather appears to be rubbery but not soft.

Pros
  • Stress Wedge technology
  • Has Finger Hammocks
  • Has increased pocket size
  • Spiral lock web pattern
  • Made with AkademaLyte leather
Cons
  • Leather construction can be improved

Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Mizuno Prospect GXC105 catcher’s mitt is probably the best catcher’s mitt for high school and youth players currently available in the market. It has features designed to help younger players improve their catching skills.

First is the PowerClose Technology that helps younger players who are struggling to have a secure grip on the ball to close the mitt with less hassle and effort which is essential as a catcher. It also has PowerLock technology to further help for easy mitt open and close by removing the last two loops on the webbing to increase flexibility and to make sure that the catcher retains his secured grip once the mitt is closed.

The glove features a PU ButterSoft Palm Liner that is incredibly soft without sacrificing durability. It also has Mizuno’s exclusive Parashock Palm Pad that efficiently absorbs the impact from catching aggressive pitches to minimize the risk of pain and to reduce the sting feeling when catching.

The Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Catcher’s Mitt is available in both right and left-hand throwers and comes in 32.5-inch size. It is also made with soft leather making it easier to break-in for immediate use, however, some stated that the leather is a little too soft and tends to lose its structure quicker.

Pros
  • PowerClose Technology for easy mitt open and close
  • PowerLock Technology for a secured grip
  • PU ButterSoft Palm Liner
  • Parashock Palm Pad
  • Easy to break-in
Cons
  • The leather construction can be stiffer

Rawlings R9 Youth Pro Taper Catcher’s Mitt

The R9 Youth Pro Taper Catcher’s Mitt is another great option for younger players seeking for a competitively durable glove that is easy to use. This glove is constructed with an all-leather shell which embodies incredible softness and lightweight feel without sacrificing durability. It has a break-in rating of 80% factory and 20% player for a significantly quicker and easier break-in process for that constant game-ready feel.

The mitt has a reinforced palm pad that softens ball impact to protect you from injuries and sting feeling due to fast-paced pitches. It also has added thumb loop and finger back lining for added comfort and protection.

It has an open back design which is especially helpful for catchers giving them more control and flexibility over their hand and wrist movements. This mitt utilizes a 1-Piece Solid web pattern that creates a consistent and deep pocket when catching pitches. It also provides better security to prevent the ball from escaping and rebounding from your grip.

The Rawlings R9 Youth Pro Taper Catcher’s Mitt has a 32-inch circumference and is available for right and left-hand throwers. Others noticed that the leather shell is a little too soft making the gloves lose the shape quicker after regular use.

Pros
  • Made with all-leather shell
  • Easy to break-in
  • Has reinforced palm pad
  • Has thumb loop and finger back lining
  • Has an open-back design
  • 1-Piece Solid web pattern
Cons
  • The leather construction can be stiffer

Things to Consider Before Buying a Catcher’s Mitt

Purchasing Baseball Catcher's Mitt

Right Hand Throw vs. Left Hand Throw Mitt

On e-commerce websites like Amazon, you can find both types of mitt (Left Hand Mitt and Right Hand Mitt).

But, sometimes, buyers get confused, and they purchase a mitt for the wrong hand. So, you should be careful about that.

Now, the question is,

How to tell if the mitt is for left hand or right hand?

On the major e-commerce websites, they clearly state that a particular mitt is for “Left Hand” or “Right Hand.”

On Amazon, you’ll see that mostly they describe it as “Left Hand Throw” or “Right Hand Throw.”

Left Hand Throw: The “Left Hand Throw” means the player who throws a ball using his left hand, and therefore, he’ll need a mitt for his right hand.

Right Hand Throw: The “Right Hand Throw” means that the player who throws a ball using his right hand, and therefore, he’ll need a mitt for his left hand.

So, if you throw a ball with the left hand, then you need to buy a mitt of “Left Hand Throw,” “Right Hand Glove,” “LHT,” and “RHG.”

While, if you throw a ball with the right hand, then you need to buy a mitt of “Right Hand Throw,” “Left Hand Glove,” “RHT,” and “LHG.”

Easy to Break-In

Your new catcher’s mitt must be easy to break-in.

If you go to a shop, and the shopkeeper tries to sell you a baseball glove by saying that there is no need to break-in, then he is lying.

Whether you are purchasing a 350$ catcher’s mitt or just a 45$ glove, there is at least little requirement of breaking in.

The break-in time may be less because the company has already done some work on it. But, if someone says, there is no need for a break-in, and then it is not correct.

So, if your mitt is easy to break-in, then the glove will adjust according to your hand quickly. Otherwise, you may have to try some methods to break in the mitt.

But, after breaking in the mitt, it does not affect the performance.

So, it is incorrect to say that the mitt, which is easy to break-in, will give better performance as compared to other mitts that take some time.

You can watch this video to learn about how to break-in the glove. You can also watch this video that also explains about breaking in mitts.

Softball vs. Baseball Catcher’s Glove

There is a little difference between the baseball and softball mitt.

As the softball is larger than the baseball therefore, to catch the ball, softball mitts have deeper pockets and thinner sidewalls.

So, do not buy a softball mitt by thinking that both the games are similar. This mistake can affect your performance. So, it’ll be good to acquire all the information about how baseball gloves are different from softball gloves.

Leather Quality of Mitt

The quality of the leather is a significant factor that determines the price of a mitt.

Usually, the cheap mitts are made from synthetic leather or the pigskin leather. So, they are soft and not very durable.

While high-priced gloves & mitts are made from high-quality leather that can be from steer hide or the leather from exotic animals.

You should note that the quality of leather determines how many seasons your mitt will last.

So, please, do not take it as the cheap leather mitts will be a hurdle in your performance.

The only difference quality of leather creates the durability of the mitt.

For young players, the quality of the leather is not a deal-breaker.

If a 12-year-old baseball catcher buys a 300$ mitt because of its durability, then he may not be able to use it for the next 2 to 3 years. At this age, the body grows, and after one or two years, he will need another glove.

So, in my opinion, for youth, there is no need to invest in high-quality leather mitts, because you have to buy another one after some time.

If you can afford it, then go ahead, your son or daughter will really love that mitt.

Pocket Area of the Mitt

Your glove should form a functional pocket that can hold a fast coming baseball.

With the perfect size pocket area, it becomes very easy to catch and control the ball.

The pocket area really affects the performance, so if you are purchasing the mitt from a sports shop, then you should take a close look at the pocket area.

If the pocket area is shallow, then it may be challenging to catch and hold the balls. At the same time, a deep pocket gives you comfort and helps you to capture and hold the ball in your mitt quickly.

So, the catchers should go for the mitts with a deep pocket.

Mitts with Adjustable Strap

In some catcher’s mitt, you’ll get an adjustable strap.

This strap is beneficial to tighten or loosen the mitt.

But, mostly, you’ll not find it in the mitts and gloves because it is not very necessary.

Yes, if your mitt has an adjustable strap, it’ll be helpful and gives you another reason to buy a specific mitt.

But, it is not a deal-breaker.

So, you should not reject a good quality mitt just because of the absence of an adjustable strap.

There are very fewer mitts in which you’ll find an adjustable strap.

Yes, it is helpful for some players, but for most of the players, it is not necessary.

If you want to see a budget-friendly mitt that comes with an adjustable strap, then take a look at Wilson A360 Youth Catcher’s Mitt.

While, if you want to see a high-priced mitt that offers adjustable strap, then take a look at All-Star Pro Elite CM3000SBT Catcher’s Mitt.

If you want to know more about CM3000SBT Mitt, then you should read my other article about the All Star Pro CM3000SBT Review.

Padding

The catcher’s mitt should have the right amount of padding so that it can absorb the shock. But, at the same time, you should also be able to catch the balls easily.

Some infield players prefer super skin models and shallow pockets, but that depends on the position.

So, you need mitt having the right amount of padding that can absorb the impact of fast coming pitches.

Looks

This depends on person to person.

Some catchers like dark color mitts while some prefer a light one.

Here, one thing that you should consider before buying a mitt is that sometimes people buy mitts by just looking at their appearance.

The appearance of the glove matters, but the performance is more important than looks.

I think almost all the mitts are nice looking. You just need to take proper care of it and clean it from time to time.

Brands that make Catcher’s Glove

Many popular brands manufacture youth catcher’s mitt for baseball players.

But, some brands dominate the field of catcher’s mitt.

Best Brands that Manufacture Catchers Mitt

In most of the cases, young players prefer buying mitts of the below-mentioned brands:

  • Wilson
  • Rawlings
  • Akadema
  • Mizuno
  • All-Star

It doesn’t mean that the brands other than the above mentioned don’t manufacture good mitts.

There are also some other brands like Easton, Nokona, Marucci, Louisville Slugger, and a few more that manufacture good quality mitts and gloves.

But, as I told earlier, in the market of the mitt, some brands are more dominant over others.

Price

You can buy a catcher’s mitt in the range of 35$ to 400$.

It depends on you how much you want to spend.

One thing to keep in mind is that, if you are buying a mitt for youth like 12 or 13 years old players, then you should not purchase an expensive glove.

The high-priced mitts are more durable and last for many seasons. But, at this age, children grow fast.

Therefore, the mitt they are using now may not be a proper fit for them after 2 years.

So, you may have to buy another mitt of large size after 2 to 3 years.

But, if you can afford a high-priced mitt again after 2 years, then go ahead. Your son or daughter will really love professional mitt.

However, as a general rule, in 2021, you can find a good mitt at under $100. But, if you want to invest, then you can also find a $300 mitt.

Perfect Sized Mitt

When buying a catcher’s mitt, size is one of the most important things.

You can ignore design, looks, adjustable strap, or brand, but you can’t ignore the size.

I can’t give enough stress on that.

The mitts are measured differently as compared to the baseball glove. The mitts are measured from the circumference of the glove for capturing the entire catching area of the mitt.

Generally, under 13 years old catchers need 32.5 inches or less, while for above 13 years old catchers, they need 32.5 inches or more.

What size catcher’s mitt good for high school?

The most common size of the catcher’s mitt for any child in the High School age is between 32.5 to 34 inches. Some children prefer a large glove with a larger catching surface, and some prefer small mitt for a quicker ball transfer. On the other hand, for the 13 to 14 years old children, 32-inch catcher mitt can be the right choice.

What size catcher’s mitt good for the youth?

When it comes to the young baseball catcher, sometimes it depends on the ability of the catchers, which demand their defensive status and acquire their own pitcher’s trust.

In every game, the ability of the catcher to receive the ball makes a difference in every game they play. In general, young catchers of 8 to 10 years old wear 30 inches to the 31-inch mitt. On the other hand, children among the ages between 11years to 13years can wear mitt size 30 to 32 inches.

How to Measure Size of a Catcher’s Mitt?

There is a difference between a baseball glove and a catcher’s mitt as the mitt doesn’t have individual fingers. The mitts are designed in such a way that they can control wild pitches more comfortably than any outfielder’s glove.

Because the construction of the mitt is different from the glove, therefore, a different way to measure the size is required. The circumference measures the catcher’s mitts, and they can range from 31 to 34 ½ inches. This is the overall size for the standard mitts from the top brands. To get a more specific size, you may need to have a more customized mitt.

To find out more about this, please click here

Final Words

These are not the only mitts that are available out there.

There are also some other great mitts that you can try and purchase because without it, you can’t become a good catcher.

Even, you should also try a different mitt in this year, and see how it goes. There are many great options available in 2021.

But, whenever you go out for purchase, make sure you understand that a high-priced mitt will last for a few years because of the high-quality leather. You may also want to buy a glove that helps you in catching signals.

So, you may not want to spend that much amount on catchers gloves for high school baseball because you may have to replace the glove after some time.

But, you should also note that the high-priced mitt also takes some time to break in. You can’t expect that both the high-priced and budget-friendly glove will break-in at the same amount of time.

The other features, like design, adjustable, are essential factors, but they are not the deal-breakers.

I hope that you had found some helpful information and get to know about some of the best catchers mitts of 2021 that can be used by high school baseball players.

If you have any questions, feel free to ask in the comment section. I’ll try to answer it as soon as possible.

Want to share it with your friends?

Vijay Singh
I started playing Baseball when I was 13 years old. I never made to MLB or any big league, but played enough to share some knowledge.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *